Two group health quotes compared by company and employee premium shares.

Two group health quotes land on your desk. One shows a lower monthly premium. Before you choose, pick one employee and follow the dollars from the carrier’s bill to that employee’s paycheck. Then repeat the exercise for someone who covers a family. A quote that looks attractive at the company level can look quite different to the people enrolling.

Give both carriers the same starting point

For a fair comparison, ask both carriers to quote the same effective date and the same employees and dependents. Mark which employees want coverage for themselves, a spouse, children or a family. If one proposal includes a spouse the other leaves out, ask for a corrected quote before comparing totals. Use a secure channel for the census and keep names out of any worksheet you circulate for discussion.

Separate the company bill from the payroll deduction

For each quote, write down three numbers for each coverage tier: the monthly premium, the dollars the business would contribute and the balance the employee would pay. Compare the quotes using the same employer contribution first. You can then see what changes when you adjust the contribution.

For example, suppose an employee-only quote is $600 a month and your business proposes contributing $450. The employee share would be $150 per month. If a second quote is $570 and you keep the same $450 contribution, the employee share would be $120. These are sample figures. For a family quote, run the calculation again using your proposed contribution toward dependents. Before sharing paycheck amounts, have payroll convert the monthly balance to your actual pay schedule.

Compare what happens when someone uses the plan

Ask for each plan’s Summary of Benefits and Coverage. This standardized summary helps you compare how plans cover common services. Put the two summaries side by side and find the same service in each, such as a specialist visit. Write down whether the deductible applies, what the employee pays and any limitations listed. Use the coverage examples to understand how the benefits work. An individual employee’s bill will depend on the care they receive.

Consider a team based in Beckley with employees who travel to Charleston for specialist visits. Ask each carrier about the exact office and hospital under the specific network being quoted. If an employee lives across the Virginia line, include that location in the questions. Give employees a private way to check their own doctors and prescriptions.

Get a decision-ready comparison

Ask for a one-page comparison showing the total monthly employer cost, the employee share in each coverage tier and two or three differences in how the plans cover care. List unanswered questions with the name of the person checking them. For example, if the hospital network is still unconfirmed, keep that question open until the carrier answers it.

Preparing for a renewal in Beckley, Summersville, Lewisburg or elsewhere in West Virginia or Virginia? Bring your renewal proposal, competing quotes and proposed contribution to a consultation. Explore our employee benefits services or contact Songer Insurance to review the comparison together.

Insurance and Medicare rules, availability and costs can change. This article provides general information and is not a guarantee of plan eligibility or benefits.